Marco Sgarbi, professor of philosophy at Ca’ Foscari University had to prepare this very important 5 minute presentation, final phase of his ERC bid application. His main challenge was to be able to explain to a very diverse panel, this whole new branch of philosophy – epistemology of medicine – which he intends to … create, and study for the next 5 years. We opted to prepare a presentation where the audience could easily grasp the context, and compare what is the grand narrative today with what prof.Sgarbi proposes to establish as a whole new discipline.